Our Review ProcessOur reviews are based on extensive research and, when possible, hands-on testing. Each time you make a purchase through one of our independently-chosen links, we’ll receive a percentage of the proceeds. Read more about how we’re supported here.
The best cat insurance could save you thousands of dollars over the course of your cat’s life, giving you both peace of mind and a happier wallet. On the other hand, the wrong insurance is both a headache and a money drain. So how do you choose the right provider? We’re here to help.
We’ve gone deep to analyze the top pet insurance providers on the market, evaluating rates, policies, and customer service.
Top 9 Pet Insurance Providers Reviewed
Get a Quote
Get a Quote
Get a Quote
Get a Quote
Get a Quote
Get a Quote
Get a Quote
Get a Quote
Get a Quote
Get a Quote
To compare costs, we’ve requested quotes from each company using the same fictional cat profile: a neutered 3-year old domestic shorthair living in Beverly Hills, California. His name is Prince Myshkin and he’ll be helping you to compare the rates offered by the 9 insurance providers on this list.
After hours of research, our number one recommendation is Healthy Paws, a company that offers affordable premiums, flexible policies, and unlimited lifetime coverage.
But there’s no one-size-fits-all in pet insurance. Choosing the best insurance policy for your cat requires an understanding of the business and your unique needs. We’ve reviewed a total of 9 of the top insurance companies in 2020.
Before we jump into the reviews, keep reading to learn the why of pet insurance, which types of plans tend to save the most, and more.
Michelle Schenker, COO and founder of Canine Journal, recalls the terrifying moment when a Copperhead snake bit her new pup.
An incident with a backyard snake forced Michelle to choose between losing Lily and paying for an antivenom treatment that cost $1,700.
“For most, this financial decision, especially on a dog who was new to our family, would have seemed insane but lucky for us we had signed Lily up for pet insurance with Petplan the week we adopted her because we have seen minor benefits of hedging your risks with our other dogs….I am thankful everyday we had the ability to make that choice so quickly to treat her because now we cannot imagine our family without her in it.”
In an article published on the Humane Society Veterinary Medical Association site, Barry Kipperman, DVM, DACVIM describes economic euthanasia as a “disease in need of prevention”.
From dental cleaning to antivenom treatments to stem cell therapy, today’s veterinary treatments run the gamut from seemingly mundane to cutting-edge. And they’re never cheap.
Treating a cat who swallowed a string could cost $2,910. A broken leg could cost $3,267 dollars. Urinary tract disease could cost $1,239. Devastating illnesses like cancer could bring home bills as high as $40,000.
Also Read: How Much Does it Cost to Own a Cat?
In a world where veterinary medical treatments can rack up bills in the tens of thousands, economic euthanasia is a reality.
Choosing to save money – or dodge bankruptcy – rather than save your pet’s life is a decision that involves anguish, guilt, shame, and regret for both pet guardian and their veterinarian.
In the comparison table below, we’ve highlighted some of the most important features of each product. You’ll find more detailed information about each product later in the article.
Choosing a good pet insurance can give you peace of mind when catastrophe arrives. As Ms. Schenker said, it gives you the ability to make the life-saving choice without worrying that it will leave you penniless.
Pet Insurance Can Provide Peace Of Mind, But It’s Not Always A Good Investment.
There’s no such thing as a standardized pet insurance policy. Many will slam you with exclusions when you need coverage most.
Dealing with a pet insurance provider can feel like walking through a minefield of exclusions. Remember that while they can afford to cover some – or most – of those costs that you can’t, an insurance provider is like a casino. The house always wins.
Broadly defining and excluding pre-existing conditions helps to ensure that the insurance company stays ahead rather than going broke to the policyholders most likely to take out frequent large claims.
While no pet insurance provider will cover pre-existing conditions, providers’ definitions vary from provider to provider and on a case-by-case basis.
It’s not unlikely that you’ll make a claim on what you thought was a new condition, only for the insurance provider to tell you that it was linked to a condition treated years ago. Claims are frequently denied under the pretense of a pre-existing condition exclusion.
In Some Cases, Creating A Dedicated Savings Account Is The Practical Choice.
A dedicated savings account is the practical choice when paying for wellness visits. Because regular checkups seldom cost over $250 each year, you’re better off putting money aside than paying for coverage you don’t need.
When we start discussing huge bills, however, pet insurance gives you an advantage.
Pet insurance allows you to use other people’s money to pay bills your savings account can’t touch.
As soon as you start using pet insurance, you have access to 100% of the benefits offered by your pet insurance provider.
This means that if your cat develops a urethral blockage one week after your coverage begins, the insurance company will cover their percentage of the bill.
If you opt for a savings account and start putting 10% of your income away today, it could take months or years to grow a fund capable of paying for urinalysis, catheterization, and hospital stays.
It’s A Poor Choice For Uninsured Cats Who Suffer From Preexisting Conditions.
If your cat has already been through the medical wringer with surgeries, serious illnesses, and other health issues, it’s unlikely that you’ll be able to get much value out of pet insurance.
Jennifer Brown, pet owner and former pet insurance policyholder, liked the idea of insuring her dogs.
After adopting her first pup in 2006, Jennifer discussed her options with her veterinarian, who discouraged the choice to get pet insurance. According to the vet, the dog’s few existing issues would lead to a slew of denied claims and a policy that wasn’t worth the monthly premium.
When a new employee benefit package brought pet insurance to the Brown household, the vet’s suggestion was proven right. Declined claims were a constant theme for both of Jennifer’s dogs.
“I just save money or use a credit card when necessary,” she concluded, because “pet insurance is simply not worth it.”
If you’ve determined that pet insurance is right for you and your cat, how do you choose the best pet insurance provider?
Choose A Plan That Provides Quality Coverage At A Price You Can Afford.
Don’t be afraid to toggle deductibles, maximums, and reimbursement percentages to get the premium that works for your budget.
Another benefit of flexible rates is that you can adjust them over time. As your cat ages and the premiums increase, you can offset those age adjustments by changing your deductible and reimbursement rate.
Don’t Underestimate The Importance Of Good Customer Service.
A sick cat is stressful enough and, supposedly, your insurance provider exists to give you peace of mind. Believe it or not, a phone call with your insurance provider shouldn’t leave you pathologically ripping up loose papers on your desk or muttering expletives to the tune of never-ending hold music.
Test a prospective provider’s customer service by giving them a test run – ask questions through the website’s chat feature, call their customer support line, and check for 24/7 support. Remember that most customers won’t hesitate to let the world know about their experience, so read customer reviews to learn how the company treats policyholders.
If you spot numerous reviews complaining about a disappointing customer support team, vague policy information, unreliable reimbursement, and soaring premiums, you can assume this pet insurance provider will cause more headaches than it solves.
Choose A Provider That Offer Extensive Coverage And Check Customer Reviews To Ensure That You’re Getting The Coverage You Expect.
At this point, you won’t find a pet insurance provider who covers pre-existing conditions. That’s a fact of buying pet insurance.
Another fact of pet insurance is the reality that your provider’s definition of pre-existing conditions isn’t always spelled out in their policy and these definitions aren’t uniform across all providers.
Some providers don’t cover hereditary conditions or have limitations on them.
Read each provider’s website to see which conditions are covered under each plans.
Select A Plan That Reimburses A Percentage Of The Actual Vet’s Bill, Not A Standard Charge.
Some insurance providers base their reimbursements on “usual and customary” charges. Insurance providers calculate these rates based on national surveys, internal data, and knowledge of your area.
These usual and customary charges are not appropriate for a real-world billing scenario. Choose a reimbursement plan based on the care your cat receives in reality.
Choose A Policy With A Reimbursement Maximum That Works For You.
Choosing a maximum is a matter of understanding what you’re willing to pay and what your cat needs.
Like everything else in a flexible policy, it’s a good idea to toggle your maximum payout to determine how the changes will affect your premiums. A higher maximum will lead to higher premiums, but the impact might be less than you expect.
Remember that lower annual maximums will lead to higher out-of-pocket expenses in a catastrophe, so shop around and find a balance that works for you in both the short-term and the long-term.
In order to evaluate each of these pet insurance providers, I’ve combed the providers’ sites, evaluated their policies, and read customer reviews on Yelp and Consumer Affairs, along with reviews on sites like Reviews.com, PetInsuranceU, Wirecutter, Consumer Reports, and Canine Journal.
To compare costs, I requested quotes from each company using the same fictional cat profile: a neutered 3-year old domestic shorthair living in Beverly Hills, California. His name is Prince Myshkin and he’ll be helping you to compare the rates offered by the 8 insurance providers on this list.
#1 Embrace Pet Insurance for Cats Review
How Affordable Is Embrace Pet Insurance For Cats?
Embrace pet insurance plans are highly adjustable, allowing you to carve out the premium and coverage combination that works for you. The company offers 70%, 80%, and 90% reimbursements based on your veterinary bills. Your choice of deductible ranges from $200 to $1,000 and you have an annual maximum of $5,000 to $30,000.
Vital Cost Statistics:
- Flexible deductible between $200 and $1000.
- Annual payout maximum up to $30,000 in most states.
- Choose a reimbursement percentage of 70%, 80%, or 90%.
How Extensive Is Embrace Pet Insurance Coverage?
This pet insurance provider offers flexible plans covering “all of your pet’s unexpected accidents & illnesses”.
Cats up to age 14 are eligible for new accident and illness policies and will remain covered as they age, while new applicants over the age of 15 are restricted to accident-only coverage.
Although the primary plans cover strictly accidents and illness, Embrace offers an additional Wellness Rewards plan, which works as a flexible savings account covering you for up to $650 in routine care expenses. Note that prescription drug coverage is included in every accident and illness plan.
What Do Customers Think Of Embrace Pet Insurance?
On Yelp, 134 reviewers give Embrace a 3 out of 5 star rating. Considering the fact that insurance provider reviews have a negativity bias, this isn’t terrible – it’s also not great.
Negative reviews revolve around the provider’s apparent tendency to link unrelated conditions and call them pre-existing, using this as a way to deny claims. Other reviewers describe Embrace as a compassionate, affordable choice.
It’s important to note that Embrace allows you to request a free medical history review at signup. By requesting this review, you’ll learn which conditions will be deemed pre-existing and for how long. If you aren’t happy with the results of the review, you can take advantage of Embrace’s 30-day money-back guarantee.
The Bottom Line: Is Embrace Pet Insurance A Good Choice For Cats?
Embrace offers some of the most extensive coverage on the market at a reasonable price. Although customer experiences aren’t universally perfect, Embrace has a generally good reputation for processing and accepting claims, providing good customer service, and leaving policyholders satisfied.
- Covers hereditary conditions
- Covers a wide range of conditions and treatments
- Reimbursements are based on actual medical costs
- Gives you a $50 “Healthy Pet Deductible” benefit every year that you don’t make a claim
- According to customer reviews, Embrace is inclined to deny claims on the pretense that unrelated conditions are linked and thus pre-existing
#2 Trupanion Cat Insurance Review
How Affordable Is Trupanion Pet Insurance For Cats?
Trupanion reimburses up to 90% and comes with no payout limits. All claims are based on actual veterinary costs, not averages and customary charges.
Trupanion’s deductibles work on a per-condition basis, rather than annually. This deductible system is good for younger cats with a future of chronic illness, but could cost you if your cat suffers from a series of disparate conditions.
Vital Cost Statistics:
- Offers annual coverage limits of $5,000, $10,000, and unlimited
- Choose a deductible of between $50 and $1,000
- Choose a reimbursement level of 70%, 80%, or 90%
How Extensive Is Trupanion Pet Insurance Coverage?
Instead of offering three or more policies of differing levels, Trupanion offers a single flexible comprehensive policy that covers surgery, diagnostics, medications, and other treatments for illnesses and accidents.
For customers looking to beef up their policy, Trupanion offers two optional additional coverage packages. One is a recovery and complementary care package, which covers various therapies not typically included within traditional policies, including rehabilitative care, acupuncture, chiropractic care, and homeopathy.
The second additional package is a pet owner assistance package, which covers expenses outside of the vet’s office, including ads and rewards for lost pets, emergency boarding, liability coverage for property damage caused by your pet, and cremation and burial in the case of your pet’s accidental death.
Note that the company doesn’t offer wellness coverage. The Trupanion site doesn’t shy away from addressing this fact, explaining that “Trupanion was founded to help pets get the emergency care they need, not to help pet owners with routine payments.”
What Do Customers Think About Trupanion Pet Insurance?
On Yelp, Trupanion has a 2.5 out of 5 star rating based on 441 reviews. Many customers say that the company wrongly denied their claims for various reasons. These reviews also indicate that Trupanion’s customer support skills are less than satisfactory, describing hours spent on the phone, either waiting on hold or struggling to get results out of uncooperative staff.
Despite these negative experiences, Trupanion doesn’t have a bad reputation with everyone. This popular insurance provider has a 9.6 out of 10 star rating on ConsumersAdvocate.org and an 8.9 out of 10 star rating on Trustpilot.
The Bottom Line: Is Trupanion Pet Insurance A Good Choice For Cats?
In Reviews.com’s roundup of the best pet insurance providers, Trupanion placed as a runner-up, lagging behind Figo, which was named best pet insurance overall, and Healthy Paws, which the reviewer described as good for cats and small dogs.
- Offers comprehensive coverage
- A well-respected leader in the pet insurance space
- Reimbursements are based on vet bills
- High annual maximums
- Can be more expensive than other providers
#3 Pawp Pet Insurance Alternative Review
Described as “like pet insurance, but better”, Pawp helps you to keep your pets protected without the complications and expense of traditional insurance.
For a flat monthly fee of $19, Pawp provides $3,000 of annual coverage on all medical emergencies arising from an accident, illness, or a pre-existing condition. This emergency fund format means that you don’t need to deal with exclusions, co-pays, or deductibles. Up to 6 pets are covered on a single plan and there are no age limits.
To help keep your cat healthy before they have an accident or get sick, Pawp also acts as a digital health clinic. Customers have 24/7 access to a team of veterinarians ready to answer questions and provide personalized support.
How Affordable Is Pawp?
Pawp costs $19 per month, regardless of your pet’s health background, age, location, or breed. You can add up to 6 pets to a single plan and that monthly rate will remain the same. Typical providers give a 0-10% discount for additional pets, so its flat rate structure makes Pawp an extremely competitive choice for multiple-pet homes.
For that $19 monthly fee ($228 per year), you’ll get a $3,000 annual emergency fund. This fund is restricted to a one-time payout, so it won’t apply to multiple emergencies in a single year, even if both of the bills add up to less than $3,000. If your bill is greater than $3,000, you’ll pay the difference. Your fund replenishes every year on your sign-up date.
In addition to this emergency fund, you’ll receive 24/7 access to a team of dedicated veterinarians. Pawp covers payments at all veterinary clinics. The company pays your veterinarian directly, so there are no reimbursements.
What Does Pawp Cover?
Pawp’s emergency fund only covers services that relate to emergency situations.
According to Pawp, emergency situations are those that require immediate veterinary care, such as seizures, severe bleeding, and difficulty breathing. Before you’re able to qualify for coverage, you must communicate with a Pawp veterinarian to confirm that your cat is having a medical emergency.
Pawp does not cover routine care like vaccines, deworming, and check-ups, nor does it cover any follow-up appointments for emergency care or treatment for secondary issues related to a previously-covered emergency.
Instead, the Pawp digital health clinic provides expert insights into your cat’s health via live chat and, eventually, video calling. Within 2 minutes, you’ll connect with an experienced vet who can answer general questions and help you decide what to do about more serious concerns.
What Do Customers Think Of Pawp?
As a new addition to the marketplace, Pawp hasn’t had a chance to receive a lot of customer reviews. Though they only have a few reviews, customer feedback has been positive so far.
For example, Pawp customer Lewis D. from New York says that “I have two dogs and pet insurance quoted me $215 a month for basic coverage. $19 a month to keep BOTH my pets safe is truly a lifesaver.”
The Bottom Line: Is Pawp A Good Choice For Cats?
Pawp is a good option for those who want protection in the case of catastrophic illnesses or accidents and don’t want to deal with all of the restrictions, fine print, and other complexities of traditional insurance.
For just over $200 a year, you get a $3,000 savings account and access to a dedicated team of veterinarians. That’s a good value, particularly for multi-pet homes.
While its digital health center is a valuable asset and the emergency fund can help you out when your cat gets hurt or sick, Pawp isn’t perfect.
It covers just one bill per year, whether that emergency treatment costs $800 or $3,400. Non-emergency services like dental care or even post-emergency follow-ups are not covered.
While one-time accidents and illnesses can take a chunk out of your wallet, recurring treatment for long-term conditions is what will cost the most. Pawp’s team of veterinarians can help you manage these conditions, but after that first annual bill, this provider doesn’t provide any additional financial support.
- One of the most affordable options for multi-pet homes
- No exclusions for pre-existing conditions
- Available to cats of all ages
- Gives you a $3,000 emergency fund
- You get 24/7 access to qualified veterinarians
- Only covers emergencies
- Hasn’t received a lot of customer reviews
#4 Figo Pet Insurance for Cats Review
This new entrant to the pet insurance industry is fully tech-integrated for the 21st century, but is it a strong choice for your cat?
How Affordable Is Figo Pet Insurance For Cats?
Figo’s policies are some of the most flexible ones you’ll find. You can choose reimbursement rates of 60%, 70%, 80%, 90%, or 100%. Figo’s annual deductibles range from $50 to $500. Their three payout levels offer $10,000, $14,000, and unlimited reimbursement annually.
Vital Cost Statistics:
- Offers annual coverage limits of $10,000, $14,000, and unlimited
- Choose an annual deductible of between $50 and $500
- Choose a reimbursement level of 60%, 70%, 80%, or 90%
How Extensive Is Figo Pet Insurance Coverage?
Figo covers veterinary fees, emergency care, hereditary conditions, surgery, prescription medications, chronic conditions, specialty care, and other treatments common to most accident and illness coverage. Members of the Ultimate plan gain access to additional coverage, including a mortality benefit and vacation cancellation.
Figo insurance doesn’t have any age cutoffs, allowing you to insure cats aged 23 years and over. Their premiums for older cats are considerably lower than those offered by other providers.
What Do Customers Think Of Figo Pet Insurance?
On Yelp, Figo Pet Insurance has a 3.5 out of 5 star rating based on 65 customer reviews. On Trustpilot, the company has a 9.1 out of 10 star rating. This Chicago-based company receives strong reviews overall, but it’s not all smiley customer service, short waiting periods, and responsive apps. Figo started in 2015 and things are changing rapidly. Most negative reviews talk about increased premiums and a changing structure that some customers view as a bait-and-switch scheme.
Lexi N. of Encinitas, California, said that: “The platform is easy to use and the customer service is good, no doubt, but unfortunately I cannot continue to be part of a service that raises premiums 50%-100% every year.”
The Bottom Line: Is Figo Pet Insurance A Good Choice For Cats?
In Reviews.com’s list of the best pet insurance providers, Figo was ranked as the number one best provider on the market. The reviewer pointed to the company’s range of unexpected perks and great customer service as outstanding factors.
Indeed, Figo does offer a few features that don’t come standard among pet insurance providers. For example, coverage comes with the Pet Cloud, a cloud-based medical history and planning application that allows you to manage your cat’s insurance claims and medical life from your smartphone.
In addition to medical management, the Pet Cloud is a full-spectrum pet management app with interesting features like pet geolocation and pet-specific landmark discovery.
Figo is currently one of the best providers out there, but it’s not perfect. When we’re looking at a company that issued its first policy three years ago and which has since sent premiums continuously higher, it’s hard to predict where the customer experience will go from here.
- Offers a great customer support experience
- The PetCloud makes it easy to organize your cat’s medical life
- Short reimbursement wait time
- Flexible policies make it possible to adapt the plan to suit your financial preferences
- Extensive coverage
- A newcomer to the pet insurance business – it’s unclear how drastically the provider will change or how premiums will increase as they become established in the industry
#5 Petplan Pet Insurance for Cats Review
Petplan has been in existence for over 40 years and is backed by Allianz, a leading property and casualty insurance company.
How Affordable Is Petplan Pet Insurance For Cats?
Petplan offers customizable plans with flexible annual limits varying from $2,500 to unlimited and flexible deductibles that are either paid annually or on a per-condition basis. Your reimbursements range from 70% to 90% and are based on your veterinarian’s bills.
If you choose the condition-based deductible model, be certain that you classify continuing treatments as such when you file a claim.
Vital Cost Statistics:
- Choice of annual coverage amount – $2500 to unlimited
- Choice of annual deductible amount – $250 to $1,000
- You can choose your reimbursement percentage – 70%, 80%, or 90%
How Extensive Is Petplan Pet Insurance Coverage?
The company offers extensive coverage with few exclusions, offering reimbursements for illness and injury without exclusions for hereditary conditions. Petplan’s comprehensive coverage includes dental care, dermatology, neurology, alternative therapies, and rehabilitation.
Unlike most other pet insurance providers, Petplan has no upper age limit, making it worth considering if you’d like to insure an older cat.
Petplan insurance is available under three standardized coverage plans. If you’d prefer a customized plan, you can adjust different aspects of the flexible policy to get the rates you want.
Policyholders with annual reimbursement of $15,000 or more are eligible for additional benefits, including coverage for ads and rewards if your cat is lost, behavioral therapy, and kennel fees. This insurance provider doesn’t offer wellness coverage, which isn’t a bad thing – wellness coverage tends to bump up premiums without offering anything you couldn’t cover with an ordinary savings account.
What Do Customers Think Of Petplan Pet Insurance?
Petplan is a generally well-regarded pet insurance company, but it’s not universally loved. On Yelp, customer sentiments are divided, giving it a 3 out of 5 star rating based on 376 reviews. When the reviews are negative, they talk about premium hikes and broadly defined pre-existing conditions.
The Bottom Line: Is Petplan Pet Insurance A Good Choice For Cats?
After over 40 years in the industry, Petplan has earned a strong reputation and is one of the leading insurance providers for pets. With adjustable premiums, diverse coverage, and 24/7 customer support, Petplan does everything a pet insurance provider needs to do.
- Unlike many other providers, Petplan has no upper age limit for signing up
- Offers discounts to veterinary professionals
- All plans cover injuries and illnesses, including those due to hereditary conditions
- Offers highly comprehensive coverage
- Flexible pricing and payout
- Costs tend to increase dramatically over time
- Charges a $3 transaction fee – higher than average
#6 Pets Best Pet Insurance for Cats Review
Based in Boise, Idaho and founded by veterinarian Dr. Jack Stephens, this pet insurance company claims to be on a mission to “end economic euthanasia of pets”.
How Affordable Is Pets Best Pet Insurance For Cats?
When you analyze Pets Best plans, one of the first things that stands out is the fact that you can’t choose unlimited reimbursement. Their base plans offer the choice of a $5,000 and a $10,000 annual maximum.
Reimbursements and deductibles are flexible – ranging from $0 to $1,000 on the deductible end and 70%, 80%, 90%, and 100% reimbursement rates.
Vital Cost Statistics:
- Offers annual coverage limits of $5000 and $10,000
- Choose a deductible of between $0 and $1,000
- Choose a reimbursement level of 70%, 80%, 90%, or $100
How Extensive Is Pets Best Pet Insurance Coverage?
Pets Best offers flexible pricing plans and a wide variety of coverage options. Unlike most pet insurance providers, who limit their coverage to cats under 14 years of age, Pets Best has no upper age limit.
The company offers three coverage levels, all of which cover a wide range of medical treatments and conditions. The two higher-tier plans include examinations, rehabilitation, prosthetics, chiropractic therapy, acupuncture, and other additional therapeutic treatments. All of their plans cover prescription medications.
Although their three primary plans don’t cover wellness visits, Pets Best offers a two-tier wellness package that you may add on to your primary policy.
What Do Customers Think Of Pets Best Pet Insurance?
Although Pets Best has moderate prices and broad coverage, customer reviews paint a picture of frustration and annoyance. 144 Yelp reviewers give it a 2 out of 5 star rating, while the BBB and Pet Insurance U both give it 3.7 out of 5 stars.
The Bottom Line: Is Pets Best Pet Insurance A Good Choice For Cats?
Pets Best isn’t the worst pet insurance on the market, but it’s not the best, either. Its premiums are middle-of-the road, the coverage is good, the policies are flexible, and payouts usually arrive before customers have a chance to worry about them. But the relatively low and inflexible annual maximums could make this a frustrating choice when those big bills arrive.
- No upper age limit for signing up
- Highly flexible pricing
- Multiple annual coverage options
- 24/7 customer service line
- Fast reimbursements
- The company’s definition of pre-existing conditions tends to be unusually broad. Customers complain that they’ve been refused coverage for a condition that Pet’s Best unexpectedly deemed to be connected to a previous issue
- Low annual maximums
#7 Pumpkin Pet Insurance for Cats Review
Launched in the spring of 2020, Pumpkin is one of the newest additions to the world of pet insurance. Owned by the world’s largest animal drug and vaccine manufacturer and headed up one of the entrepreneurs behind Ollie dog food, this company has roots in multiple parts of the veterinary and pet care industry.
Pumpkin prioritizes simplicity over flexibility. They offer a simple plan that covers accidents and illnesses. If you’re interested in wellness coverage, you can tack on Pumpkin’s preventive care pack for an additional monthly fee. The preventive care covers routine care like wellness exams, parasite screenings, and vaccinations.
Though you can toggle between three annual deductibles, Pumpkin doesn’t give you a lot of ways to adjust your coverage. Pumpkin’s coverage comes with a $7,000 annual limit for cats and a 90% reimbursement rate. There’s no way to change either of these.
According to Pumpkin sales director Beth Wymer, “It’s a very simple, smart plan. We researched the cost of veterinary care, even catastrophic events, and learned that over 99% of annual covered costs per pet are under $10,000 per dog and under $7,000 per cat.* So, we made a lot of big decisions for the pet owner.”
How Affordable Is Pumpkin Pet Insurance?
With just three deductible options, a fixed payout, and a $7,000 annual cap for cats, Pumpkin’s insurance rates aren’t very flexible and, while they’re not particularly high in the first place, their monthly rates won’t go as low as those offered by some other providers.
By providing a discount on each additional enrolled pet, Pumpkin makes itself an attractive choice for multi-pet homes. Here’s an example of a quote from the Pumpkin website:
How Extensive Is Pumpkin Pet Insurance Coverage?
Here’s a list of some of what Pumpkin covers according to this section on their website:
For an additional $11.95 per month ($143.40 annually), Pumpkin also covers three routine care services with their Preventive Essentials plan. You’ll get a full refund on your cat’s annual checkup, along with your money back on one vaccination and a yearly parasite screening.
Pumpkin believes it’s important to catch and prevent diseases early, which is why it worked directly with vets to build out the plan with the 3 essentials that each cat is recommended to get every year.
What Do Customers Think Of Pumpkin Pet Insurance?
Since its launch in April of 2020, Pumpkin hasn’t had much time to accumulate a lot of customer reviews. As of August 2020, the company has 7 reviews on Yelp. Five gave it five stars. The two other reviewers gave it 1-star ratings, both saying that Pumpkin had denied their dog’s claims.
One rejected claim was for a treatment associated with a pre-existing condition. The other reviewer said that Pumpkin refused to explain the denied claim.
Pumpkin does provide a detailed written explanation for claim denials in every claim. Pumpkin also has 5 reviews on Google. Four gave it five stars, and the fifth is the same 1-star rating that was posted on Yelp.
The Bottom Line: Is Pumpkin Pet Insurance A Good Choice For Cats?
Pumpkin’s basic plan is great if you’re looking for a simple, easy to understand offering.
We currently haven’t seen enough customer reviews to get an idea of the company’s consistency and customer service chops. Still, it looks like it could be a good option, especially for those who want a straightforward plan from an up-and-coming group of cat lovers.
- Offers extensive coverage for many services
- Accepts cats of any age 8 weeks or older
- Easy signup process
- High reimbursement percentage
- Doesn’t allow you to adjust annual payouts or reimbursements
- $7,000 yearly maximum for cats is relatively low compared to other plans
- Hasn’t received a lot of customer reviews
* Based on United States Fire Insurance Company data, August 2019. The data shows less than 1% of insured dog parents typically submit claims totaling over $10,000 in a policy year and less than 1% of insured cat parents typically submit claims totaling over $7,000 in a policy year.
Pumpkin Advertiser Disclosure:
Pumpkin Insurance Services, Inc. is responsible for this advertisement. Pumpkin Pet Insurance policies do not cover pre-existing conditions. Waiting periods, annual deductible, co-insurance, benefit limits and exclusions may apply. For full terms, visit pumpkin.care/insurancepolicy. Products, discounts, and rates may vary and are subject to change. Pumpkin Insurance Services Inc. (Pumpkin) is a licensed insurance agency, not an insurer. Insurance is underwritten by United States Fire Insurance Company, a Crum & Forster Company and produced by Pumpkin. Pumpkin Preventive Essentials is not an insurance policy. It is offered as an optional add-on non-insurance benefit. Pumpkin is responsible for the product and administration. Pumpkin Preventive Essentials is not available in all states. For full terms, visit pumpkin.care/customeragreement.
#8 Nationwide Pet Insurance for Cats Review
This well-established company has been selling pet insurance under the VPI (Veterinary Pet Insurance) name since 1982. VPI sold its first policy to a famous dog of the screen – a collie best known for portraying “Lassie”.
In 2015, Nationwide discarded the VPI name and rebranded as simply Nationwide Pet Insurance.
How Affordable Is Nationwide Pet Insurance?
While Nationwide’s comprehensive Whole Pet with Wellness plan is one of the most expensive on the market, the plan is the company’s most popular offering.
It covers almost everything you would need a pet insurance provider to cover. Unlike the lower-value plans, the comprehensive plan reimburses a percentage of real vet bills. Whole Pet with Wellness reimburses a generous 90% of your invoice, while all other Nationwide plans reimburse on a benefit schedule and limit benefits per condition.
Nationwide’s fixed annual deductibles are both good and bad. A fixed low deductible is attractive for those dealing with multiple treatments throughout the year. But if you’re someone who would rather pay a high deductible when disaster strikes and a low premium every month, your hands are tied.
Vital Cost Statistics:
- Unlimited annual maximums, but a benefit schedule will limit your benefits per condition
- $100 or $250 annual deductible
- 90% reimbursement percentage on the comprehensive plan, benefit schedule on all others
How Extensive Is Nationwide Pet Insurance Coverage?
Nationwide Pet Insurance offers three different plans: the comprehensive Whole Pet with Wellness, standard accident and illness with Major Medical, and a two-tiered wellness plan.
The Whole Pet with Wellness plan covers exams, lab tests, and x-rays, prescription medications, surgeries and hospitalization, chronic conditions, and wellness costs, along with other benefits.
The Major Medical plan offers almost the same accident and illness coverage offered by the Whole Pet with Wellness plan, but lacks a few benefits.
For instance, not all hereditary conditions are covered. If your cat has a hereditary condition that is covered by Major Medical, you’ll not be able to make a claim until after the waiting period is over.
What Do Customers Think Of Nationwide Pet Insurance?
Being a big fish in the pet insurance ocean doesn’t make Nationwide Pet Insurance any better than younger companies. In fact, it receives some of the worst reviews in the industry.
Nationwide earns a 1.4 out of 5 star rating on Pet Insurance U. Pet Insurance U gives this provider an unimpressive 1.4 out of 5 star rating. Why? The review says that taking out a policy from Nationwide means buying into premium hikes, denied claims, low payouts, limitations and exclusions, and sub-par customer service.
The Bottom Line: Is Nationwide Pet Insurance A Good Choice For Cats?
Frankly, no. In most cases, Nationwide Pet Insurance isn’t a good choice. It’s been a pet insurance leader for a long time, but this company’s inflexible policies and history of poor customer service make it the least desirable provider on this list.
- The highest-level plan has exceptionally comprehensive coverage and unlimited benefits per condition and service
- No annual benefit caps
- Policyholders may take advantage of Nationwide’s Vet Helpline, which offers live veterinary advice online
- A well-established and very stable company
- Cats over the age of 10 are not eligible for a new policy
- Less flexible than some other options available
- A higher-priced insurance
#9 PetPremium Pet Insurance for Cats Review
PetPremium, a concept of ReviMedia, is a New York-based pet insurance provider founded in 2013. It was created by Frans van Hulle and Bas Offers and aims to bring together pet insurance and pet education, serving as a comprehensive resource for pet guardians.
That mission is apparent on the PetPremium website. At first glance, you might not realize that you’re looking at a pet insurance company’s site. Instead of talking about quotes and coverage, the home page’s navigation bar directs you to articles on dog and cat breeds, pet care, and resources for those looking for a new pet.
How Affordable Is Petpremium Pet Insurance?
Although their deductibles aren’t quite as flexible as those offered by some others, PetPremium offers the standard range of benefit limits and reimbursement percentages.
Vital Cost Statistics:
- Annual benefits range from $2,500 to unlimited
- Annual deductibles of $100, $250, or $500
- Reimbursements of 70%, 80%, or 90%
How Extensive Is Petpremium Insurance Coverage?
PetPremium offers both accident-only coverage and a Total Care plan, which adds on illness coverage.
The accident-only coverage is effective for treating accidents and injuries, while the Total Coverage plan covers tests, surgeries, hospitalization, and other illness-related expenses. In addition to coverage for illnesses, the Total Care plan brings you coverage for behavioral therapy and treatment for hereditary conditions.
While PetPremium’s reimbursements were previously based on predetermined incident limits, they’re now calculated based on actual vet bills.
PetPremium also offers three tiers of wellness coverage as an add-on to your existing policy.
- The Basic plan covers up to $250 of dental cleanings, checkups, routine vaccinations, and screenings.
- For an additional $5 a month, you can level up to the Standard wellness package, which increases your coverage limit to $350 annually.
- The Prime wellness package covers up to $500 every year and includes special vaccinations, flea and heartworm treatments, blood tests, and urinalysis.
What Do Customers Think Of Petpremium Pet Insurance?
Because there are so few reviews of the company online right now, it’s difficult to evaluate the PetPremium customer experience.
On Yelp, the provider has just 2 reviews. One, created by Dan G. of New York, says that “the service is great”, explaining that after comparing quotes, PetPremium’s policy was the best value for their dog, Buddy.
The one other review tells a radically different story. Jim M. of Little Silver, New Jersey, said that he received abysmal customer service after the company covered $2,000 less than the estimated payout for his Golden Retriever’s TPLO surgery.
You can contact the company by phone, through Twitter, or by filling out the contact form on their site. If you choose to call in for support, you’ll notice that the company has limited customer support hours. You can call their customer support line 8am-9pm EST from Monday-Friday and 9am-5pm EST on Saturdays.
Many other pet insurance providers recognize the demand for 24/7 service and are available to help you at all hours of the day.
The Bottom Line: Is Petpremium Pet Insurance A Good Choice For Cats?
Founded just five years ago, PetPremium is a relatively new company and one of the less-known pet insurance providers in business today. With such a scarcity of customer reviews, it’s difficult to evaluate the claim approval process or the company’s customer service strength.
Here’s what we do know: PetPremium’s policies are flexible, their coverage is comprehensive, and their premiums are low.
- Allows you to choose any veterinarian in the United States or Canada
- Dental care is offered on every plan
- Affordable, adjustable premiums
- Has an informative website
- Reimbursements are based on actual charges
- Limited customer support
- Deductibles aren’t the most flexible
#10 Pet Assure Pet Insurance Alternative Review
With no exclusions, maximums, breed restrictions, or pages of fine print, Pet Assure is a straightforward alternative to pet insurance.
It’s a membership program that allows you to receive discounts on veterinary services. If you’ve been in other discount membership clubs like the Good Sam Club, Costco, or Sam’s Club, the model won’t feel too unfamiliar.
You pay a monthly fee, get a membership card, and get a 25% discount on veterinary services at participating clinics.
How Affordable Is Pet Assure?
There are two Pet Assure plans. One covers an unlimited number of pets and the other covers just one. Whether you have one cat, a farm, or a household full of reptiles, Pet Assure gives you the same discount regardless of who’s receiving care. With a flat rate for multi-pet households, it’s significantly cheaper than paying a different monthly premium for each pet.
Your monthly costs will vary, but most plans don’t exceed $10 per month.
For example, if Prince Myshkin’s owner works at Delta Airlines, his monthly fee would be $11 for an unlimited number of pets (including any breed or species), or $8 per month if he’s only enrolling Prince Myshkin. For a one-cat household, that adds up to $96 per year.
While insurance could save you 70-90% once you meet the deductible, Pet Assure will pay the same 25% for any expense, regardless of price.
While this discount can give you some great rewards during routine examinations, dental cleanings, diabetes management, and other lower-cost bills that might slip under your insurance deductible, it can’t match pet insurance when it comes to major expenses.
For example, if your cat has a bout of urinary tract disease and treatment costs $1,600, you’ll still pay $1,200 with Pet Assure. Assuming a $250 deductible, an insurance provider with an 80% reimbursement percentage would pay $1,080 of the bill, leaving you to cover the remaining $520.
Even if you’re paying an extra hundred dollars a year for pet insurance, the savings could be worth it when big bills arrive.
- Gives you an instant 25% discount on all in-house veterinary services and procedures
- No exclusions or maximums
- Only available through employers
How Extensive Is Pet Assure’s Veterinarian Network?
Before you get Pet Assure, be sure to check for local veterinarians in the network. Unless you live in a densely-populated area, participating veterinarians will be scarce and your regular vet may not be among the few.
For example, our friend Prince Myshkin has access to 16 veterinarians within a 10-mile radius of his home in Beverly Hills. But if he lived in Galena, Illinois, he’d have to travel 38 miles and across state lines to reach the nearest participating vet.
If your current veterinarian isn’t in the Pet Assure network, you may invite them to join.
Note, also, that Pet Assure is only available through employers. Check to see if your employer provides Pet Assure as a pet insurance alternative.
What Do Customers Think Of Pet Assure?
On TrustPilot, 47 customer reviews give Pet Assure an average rating of 4.4 out of 5 stars. Users describe the Pet Assure experience as simple and straightforward, eliminating the need to worry about filing claims and dealing with exclusions.
It’s popular among multi-pet families, who appreciate the low price and convenience of keeping all of their pets on the same plan.
The Bottom Line: Is Pet Assure A Good Choice For Cats?
Pet Assure is a no-fuss alternative to traditional insurance. Every pet is welcome, regardless of age, breed, species, or pre-existing conditions. You’ll never have to fill out a form, file a claim, or submit information about your pet’s medical history.
With 25% discounts on all in-house services, it’s a good way to save on X-rays, dental cleanings, vaccinations, and lab work. Especially if you have multiple pets in the same home, Pet Assure should pay for itself over a year of routine care.
It can help to ease the burden of catastrophic expenses, but if you’re afraid that a multi-thousand dollar bill will knock you out financially, insurance is probably a better option.
Between it only being available through employers and the relative scarcity of vets in the network of approved vendors, availability and usability can be a challenge. Before you choose Pet Assure, contact your vet or verify that there are at least a couple of participating clinics in your area.
- Doesn’t exclude any pets, regardless of age or health history
- Comes with a 24/7 lost pet recovery service
- All medical procedures and in-house veterinary services are covered
- No deductibles or limits
- Monthly fees are usually significantly lower than those offered by insurance, especially for multi-pet homes
- Relatively few vets are in the Pet Assure network, so double-check before bringing your card into a new office
- Only available through participating employers
About the author
Mallory Crusta is a writer and adventurecat enthusiast on a mission to make cats’ lives extraordinary. She’s one of the founders of Wildernesscat – a site for happy, healthy, and adventurous cats who are fueled by nature. Visit Wildernesscat for radically natural cat nutrition, home remedies, and lifestyle inspiration.