Sustainably Yours Litter Review

Share Email Pinterest Linkedin Twitter Facebook

Our Review Process

Our reviews are based on extensive research and, when possible, hands-on testing. Each time you make a purchase through one of our independently-chosen links, we’ll receive a percentage of the proceeds. Read more about how we’re supported here.

Sustainably Yours Cat Litter has three varieties available in the U.S. and two varieties available in Brazil. (In Brazil, their litter products go by the name of Viva Verde!) For the sake of this product review, we will be focusing on the three options available in the U.S., which are the Multi-Cat, Multi-Cat Plus and Multi-Cat Large Grains formulas.

The Sustainably Yours litters in this review are all made from a mixture of corn and cassava, which did a good job with absorbency, clumping, odor control, tracking and an extremely low amount of dust.

In addition, corn and cassava are both sustainable and renewable crops, and one of the goals of Sustainably Yours is to produce cat litter that is not only effective, but also environmentally friendly.

Another aspect of their environmentally friendly approach is the litter’s flushability. According to their website, Sustainably Yours litter is flushable if it is soaked for 15 minutes before flushing.

However, they do point out that there are some parasites in cat litter that have been found to harm certain mammals, so they recommend that their customers do some research before flushing. Their website also mentions that it is illegal to flush litter of any kind in the state of California.

Along with their litter being 100% sustainable, the company is also a member of The Rainforest Trust, and a portion of every Sustainably Yours purchase is donated to this organization which acquires acreage of threatened rainforest worldwide to protect and sustain natural habitats.

In addition, Sustainably Yours partners with animal shelters in the U.S. and Brazil, and also donates to programs that assist pet owners with high medical costs or other financial issues.

Ratings

  • Variety of Products – 4/5
  • Price Per Pound – 3/5
  • Multi-Cat Formulas – 3.5/5
  • Clumping Ability – 4/5
  • Long-Lasting Odor Control – 4/5
  • Natural/Alternative Options – 5/5

Overall Score: 4.5/5

How We Tested:

  • We purchased three varieties of cat litters that Sustainably Yours has to offer
  • We spent multiple weeks testing the litters on several cats
  • We did not receive these products in exchange for a favorable review, they were purchased with our own money

Brand Overview

Like with other corn- and cassava-based litters on the market, Sustainably Yours is a completely sustainable product while also being renewable, biodegradable, compostable and flushable.

One variety of Sustainably Yours Litter is the Multi-Cat Formula.

One variety of Sustainably Yours Litter is the Multi-Cat Formula.

Also, its natural starches help to form solid clumps that are easily scooped with limited crumbling, along with doing a very good job with odor control naturally.

Another variety of Sustainably Yours Litter is the Multi-Cat Plus formula.

Another variety of Sustainably Yours Litter is the Multi-Cat Plus formula.

In addition, the all-natural formula does a great job as far as limited dust is concerned when pouring and scooping, and regardless of which grain-sized formula you are using, the litter does very well when it comes to limiting tracking outside of the litter box.

A third variety of Sustainably Yours Litter is the Multi-Cat Large Grains formula.

A third variety of Sustainably Yours Litter is the Multi-Cat Large Grains formula.

Another benefit of Sustainably Yours litter is that it is naturally very light in color compared to most other litters, which can be extremely helpful when it comes to monitoring your cat’s litterbox use, meaning that you can easily notice any unusual discoloration in their urine or feces.

Products Included In This Review

Name Materials Clumping Life Stage Additional Features
Sustainably Yours Natural Multi-Cat Litter Corn & Cassava Yes All Clumping, Unscented, All-Natural, Dust-Free
Sustainably Yours Natural Multi-Cat Plus Litter Corn & Cassava Yes All Clumping, Unscented, All-Natural, Dust-Free
Sustainably Yours Natural Large Grains Litter Corn & Cassava Yes All Clumping, Unscented, All-Natural, Dust-Free

Popular Alternatives to Sustainably Yours Cat Litter:

Here are some of our favorite cat litter brands you can choose from today. Most offer a discount on your first order so you can see how your cats like it.

  1. Garfield Cat Litter
  2. World’s Best Cat Litter
  3. Okocat Cat Litter

What Kinds Of Litter Does The Brand Offer?

Sustainably Yours Cat Litter offers three different varieties, all of which are multi-cat formulas, fragrance-free and made from corn and cassava. The main difference between these varieties is the granule size; the Multi-Cat Formula has a mixture of small and large grains to balance clumping and tracking, the Multi-Cat Plus Formula uses small grains for faster clumping, and the Multi-Cat Large Grains Formula uses large grains to minimize tracking.

All three of these Sustainably Yours litter formulas offer the same benefits:

  • Made from Corn and Cassava
  • Highly Absorbent
  • Fragrance-Free
  • Clumping
  • Flushable

This litter is much different than many other available litters because of its sustainable, renewable and biodegradable ingredients, its natural fragrance-free odor control, as well as its high level of absorbency.

Some other advantages to Sustainably Yours litter are that it is virtually dust-free when pouring and scooping, its clumping abilities makes it simple to scoop with minimal clump breakage, and its naturally light color makes it easy to spot any unhealthy discoloration in your cat’s urine and feces.

When it comes to urine and feces, all three varieties did a great job when it came to immediate clumping with urine, and it also did a very good job clumping onto fecal matter. With that in mind, it’s definitely more effective and maintains a higher level of odor control if you scoop your litter boxes at least once a day, particularly if you are in a multi-cat home, which is what Sustainably Yours litter is designed for in the first place.

As for its cost-per-pound ratio, Sustainably Yours has a higher price point than other litters that you might find on the market, but when you take into consideration things like the sustainable and renewable ingredients, the flushability, the low amount of tracking, the dust-free formula, and the overall effectiveness, the investment seems worth the cost.

Product Name Type Price Per Pound Overall Rating
Sustainably Yours Natural Multi-Cat Litter Clumping $2.10 4/5
Sustainably Yours Natural Multi-Cat Litter Plus Clumping $2.20 4.5/5
Sustainably Yours Natural Large Grains Litter Clumping $2.20 4/5

#1 Sustainably Yours Natural Multi-Cat Litter

Buy On Amazon Buy On Petco

The mostly dust-free formula and sustainable ingredients make this litter a very attractive option compared to litters made from other ingredients. Also, its flushability makes it an even more attractive option when it comes to choosing an eco-friendly cat litter.

The mixture of large and small grains in Sustainably Yours Natural Multi-Cat Litter gives it a good balance when it comes to clumping and tracking.

The mixture of large and small grains in Sustainably Yours Natural Multi-Cat Litter gives it a good balance when it comes to clumping and tracking.

And, even though it’s an unscented formula, it does a surprisingly good job with odor control due to its mixture of corn and cassava which naturally eliminates odors without the use of any added chemical fragrances.

The size and consistency are a combination of large and small granules, which may seem a little unusual compared to other litters, but the combination of granule sizes are very beneficial when it comes to finding a good balance with clumping and tracking.

Category Rating
Price 3.5/5
Clumping Action 4/5
Odor Control 4/5
Dust/Mess 5/5
Scent 4/5
Easy to Scoop 4/5
Overall Rating 4/5

Pros

  • Made from sustainable ingredients
  • Highly absorbent
  • Flushable

Cons

  • Unscented
  • Some dust when pouring

This litter comes in either a 10-pound or 13-pound bag. We reviewed the 10-pound bag, which didn’t seem all that heavy compared to other litters that we have reviewed. However, the bag is not resealable and does not include an easy way to handle it while pouring it into the litter box, so be sure to keep that in mind.

#2 Sustainably Yours Multi-Cat Plus Litter

Buy On Petco

Like the Multi-Cat formula, the Multi-Cat Plus formula also comes in a 10-pound and 13-pound variety, which are both pretty easy to open and pour when filling up the litter box. Just be sure to remember that the bag is not resealable, so that’s something to keep in mind.

The smaller granules in Sustainably Yours Multi-Cat Plus Litter allow for faster clumping and absorbing, helping to make scooping easier.

The smaller granules in Sustainably Yours Multi-Cat Plus Litter allow for faster clumping and absorbing, helping to make scooping quicker and easier.

The size of the granules are a little small compared to several other litter formulas, but the smaller granule size makes it absorb urine more quickly, making the overall clumping happen more quickly.

As for odor control, since the Multi-Cat Plus variety is made from smaller granules, the quick absorbency does a really good job with immediate and long-lasting odor control. Also, the small granules and high absorbency make scooping much more quickly and easy.

Category Rating
Price 3.5/5
Clumping Action 5/5
Odor Control 4/5
Dust/Mess 3.5/5
Scent 4/5
Easy to Scoop 5/5
Overall Rating 4.5/5

Pros

  • Extremely Absorbent
  • Immediate and long-term odor control
  • All-natural ingredients

Cons

  • Some scattering outside of litter box
  • Unscented

This litter comes in either a 10-pound or 13-pound bag. We reviewed the 10-pound bag, which was easy to manage even though the bag wasn’t resealable or have a built-in handle like some other brands.

#3 Sustainably Yours Multi-Cat Large Grains Litter

Buy On Amazon Buy On Petco

Just like the other two varieties of Sustainably Yours litter, the Large Grains formula is made from corn and cassava, flushable, and designed for multi-cat homes. And, its eco-friendliness makes it all the more appealing.

The larger grains in Sustainably Yours Natural Large Grains Litter did a great job with odor control, as well as being virtually dust free.

The larger grains in Sustainably Yours Natural Large Grains Litter did a great job with odor control, as well as being virtually dust free.

Despite it being an unscented litter, it still did a good job with odor control. The corn and cassava mixture is naturally absorbent while also combating odors, and the larger grains all but eliminate dust when pouring and scooping.

The larger grains are designed to help eliminate tracking and scattering outside of the litter box, however the clumping factor is not as effective compared to the smaller sized varieties of this brand. Still, it works very well overall and helps to minimize cleanup.

Category Rating
Price 3.5/5
Clumping Action 5/5
Odor Control 3.5/5
Dust/Mess 5/5
Scent 4.5/5
Easy to Scoop 4/5
Overall Rating 4.5/5

Pros

  • Very little tracking and scattering
  • Low dust when pouring or scooping
  • Made from environmentally friendly ingredients

Cons

  • Doesn’t clump as well as smaller grain litters
  • Unscented

This litter comes in either a 10-pound or 13-pound bag. We reviewed the 10-pound bag, which was not as heavy compared to other litters that we have reviewed. That being said, the bag is not resealable and does not have a quick-release opening, so you will have to use a pair of scissors or other cutting tool to open it.

What Do Customers Think Of Sustainably Yours Cat Litter?

All three varieties of Sustainably Yours Cat Litter rated incredibly well with customers, with the Multi-Cat formula scoring 4.4 stars on Amazon, the Multi-Cat Plus formula scoring 4.4 stars on Amazon, and the Large Grains formula scoring 4.4 stars on Amazon. As with all cat litters, there are both good and bad reviews, so you may have to do some experimenting to find out what works best for your cats and what works best for you.

Keep reading to see positive and negative reviews for the varieties of Sustainably Yours Cat Litter featured above:

Positive Reviews

“This litter is pretty incredible. It clumps extremely quickly, and the clumps are extremely firm. When the cat pees overnight, the clumps I find in the morning are rock solid. My cat is a side pee-er, and I have had no issues with the clumps sticking to the side or bottom of the box.” –Frazzled Glispa, reviewing Sustainably Yours Multi-Cat Litter

“I love, love, love this litter. I use pee pads on the bottom of my cat’s litter box, and the pee solidifies before it can even touch the pee pads! I never write reviews, even on stuff I really like, but this litter is the BEST! I had to write a review. The best litter I’ve ever used.” –Ryan, reviewing Sustainably Yours Multi-Cat Plus Litter

“We have used pretty much every natural cat litter out there, pine, newspaper, corn, wheat… Once we tried this litter there was no going back. It clumps better than anything else and it holds together so when you scoop, the clump doesn’t fall apart” –J. Wittenberg, reviewing Sustainably Yours Multi-Cat Large Grains Cat Litter

Negative Reviews

“I really really wanted to like this. I love the texture and it’s organic but it does not absorb any smell. I dreaded changing the litter it smelt so bad. I have never had that problem before. I have a very small cat and she hardly does anything in there. It shouldn’t be that bad.” –EKM, reviewing Sustainably Yours Multi-Cat Litter

“Yes, it clumps well. Yes, it controls odor without perfumes. Yes, it seems to be low dust. But this is the worst for tracking. We have hardwood floors and linoleum and this stuff just gets everywhere.” –D, reviewing Sustainably Yours Multi-Cat Plus Litter

“Super clumping but smells really bad, especially when my cat uses it for #2. I mean it is nearly unbearable and if it is not super solid, you get tiny little poo flecks all mixed in. Won’t be buying it again. For the price it should be much better.” –ShaLeaKronk, reviewing Sustainably Yours Multi-Cat Large Grains Cat Litter

How Much Does Sustainably Yours Cat Litter Cost?

All three varieties of Sustainably Yours are very similar in price, with the Multi-Cat formula being $2.10 per pound, the Multi-Cat Plus formula being $2.20 per pound, and the Multi-Cat Large Grains formula being $2.20 per pound.

Overall, Is Sustainably Yours Cat Litter A Good Choice?

We have a lot of positive things to say about all three varieties of Sustainably Yours Cat Litter that we reviewed. Ultimately, all of them did very well with only a few, minor downsides. And, the downsides really depend on your personal preferences.

Sustainably Yours cat litter might seem a little bit pricey compared to other litters on the market, but you’re also paying for sustainability, renewability and flushability. In other words, your extra dollars are paying to help the environment in the long-run.

Where Is Sustainably Yours Cat Litter Sold?

Sustainably Yours Cat Litter is primarily sold online through Amazon, but is also available to purchase from other retailers.

CLICK HERE TO SHOP FOR SUSTAINABLY YOURS LITTER ON AMAZON

Avatar photo

About Michael Vogelsang

Owned by a colony of 12 cats, Michael is an animal lover, writer, musician and voice actor who has always loved having animals in his life. He and his wife enjoy their involvement with local shelters and the rescue community, as well as taking care of their ever-growing family of animals.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.